23 September 2014 @ 11:41 am
pensieve pregunta (because, alliteration)  
I've just been thinking about random HP things, as one does, and I was hoping ya'll could clarify a point about Pensieves for me.

My question is: When you are putting a memory into the pensieve for viewing, is that silvery stuff the actual memory, or just a copy? For example, if Harry decided to view the Sectumpsempra incident, and took out the memory, would he still have any recollection of the memory BEFORE looking at it again?

ETA: And if it is just a copy of the memory. Do you think this memory copying spell can be applied an unlimited number of times? Could Harry withdraw/copy that Sectumsempra memory multiple times, without any degradation? Would it being copied affect the original memory, or just dilute the copy?? I'm over-thinking this.
 
 
( Post a new comment )
vaysh[personal profile] vaysh on September 23rd, 2014 08:46 pm (UTC)
I totally go for the theory that intention plays a big part in what happens with memories in a Pensieve. Rowling's magic has a lot to do with the will and intent of the wizard or witch doing the magic. #

And yes, I can see Dumbledore using "head too crowded" as a figure of speech to explain why he himself is watching his own memories in a Pensieve. What it means to me is that a Pensieve memory is different than your own memory in some ways - you get an outsider's fresh view on what happened, also perhaps there are things in your memory that you don't consciously remember but that are still there somehow (Muggle memory works like that too ;)).