23 September 2014 @ 11:41 am
pensieve pregunta (because, alliteration)  
I've just been thinking about random HP things, as one does, and I was hoping ya'll could clarify a point about Pensieves for me.

My question is: When you are putting a memory into the pensieve for viewing, is that silvery stuff the actual memory, or just a copy? For example, if Harry decided to view the Sectumpsempra incident, and took out the memory, would he still have any recollection of the memory BEFORE looking at it again?

ETA: And if it is just a copy of the memory. Do you think this memory copying spell can be applied an unlimited number of times? Could Harry withdraw/copy that Sectumsempra memory multiple times, without any degradation? Would it being copied affect the original memory, or just dilute the copy?? I'm over-thinking this.
 
 
( Post a new comment )
[identity profile] celestlyn.livejournal.com on September 23rd, 2014 10:12 pm (UTC)
I have always assumed that they are the actual memories and once removed would not be in the person's mind until they were returned. I remember one scene when Dumbledore was removing memories from his head, 'casting them out' and into little glass vials. He was telling Harry something to the effect that it didn't do to dwell on memories and sometimes it was better to be rid of them? Canon? Movie canon? Am I dreaming? Makes me wonder if JKR has expounded further on Pensieves on Pottermore. Fandom has taken a lot of license with interpreting the whole use of Pensieves and that's good. You can probably get away with writing it however you like.
gracerene[personal profile] gracerene on September 24th, 2014 02:32 pm (UTC)
Yeah, there definitely seems to be some room for interpretation!